AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

For Thanksgiving, the choice between a stainless steel roasting pan and a nonstick one comes down to what happens after the turkey goes into the oven. Stainless steel tolerates browning, stovetop use, and metal utensils well, which makes it the stronger tool for pan gravy and years of holiday cooking. Nonstick releases food more readily and usually cleans up faster, an appealing advantage when the kitchen is busy and the pan is full of sticky drippings.

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
3
compared
3
brands
2
materials
Which thanksgiving roasting pan should you buy?
★ Top Pick
EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless S
Best Overall for Rack Flexibility
Includes both V-shaped and flat racks for different roasting setups.
See on Amazon →
Hosts planning a large turkey who have enough oven clearance and want a nonstick pan with a stated capacity.
KITESSENSU Nonstick Turkey Roa
Stated capacity of 24 pounds helps with large-turkey planning.
View on Amazon →
Cooks with limited oven or cabinet space who roast smaller portions and value nonstick release.
Glad Nonstick Roasting Pan wit
Smaller 15 × 10.3-inch footprint is easier to fit and store.
View on Amazon →
Pros & cons at a glance
EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless S
✓ Includes both V-shaped and flat racks for different roasting setups.
✗ Large footprint can be difficult to store and may challenge a crowded oven.
KITESSENSU Nonstick Turkey Roa
✓ Stated capacity of 24 pounds helps with large-turkey planning.
✗ The 17 × 14-inch footprint needs substantial oven and storage space.
Glad Nonstick Roasting Pan wit
✓ Smaller 15 × 10.3-inch footprint is easier to fit and store.
✗ 2.8-inch depth and unspecified capacity make it less suited to a large turkey.
BEST OVERALL FOR RACK FLEXIBILITY
EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless Steel Roasting Pan Set with V-Shaped and Flat Racks

EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless Steel Roasting Pan Set with V-Shaped and Flat Racks

  • ✔ Material: Stainless steel
  • ✔ Pan baking area: 17 × 13 inches
  • ✔ Pan depth: 3.5 inches
BEST FOR A LARGE TURKEY AND EASIER CLEANUP
KITESSENSU Nonstick Turkey Roasting Pan with Rack, 17 x 14 Inch

KITESSENSU Nonstick Turkey Roasting Pan with Rack, 17 x 14 Inch

  • ✔ Material: Carbon steel
  • ✔ Dimensions: 17 × 14 × 3.8 inches
  • ✔ Stated capacity: 24 pounds
BEST COMPACT PICK
Glad Nonstick Roasting Pan with Rack, 15 x 10.3 Inches

Glad Nonstick Roasting Pan with Rack, 15 x 10.3 Inches

  • ✔ Material: Carbon steel
  • ✔ Dimensions: 15 × 10.3 × 2.8 inches, excluding handles
  • ✔ Weight: 3.2 pounds

The difference is meaningful, but neither material guarantees a good roast: pan size, sturdy construction, and a rack that fits the bird matter too. Choose stainless steel if you want a pan that can move from oven to stovetop and handle repeated use. Choose nonstick if easy release and less scrubbing matter more, and you are comfortable protecting its coating. The comparison below focuses on those shared Thanksgiving decisions.

At a Glance

CriteriaStainless steel roasting panNonstick roasting panWinner
Turkey browningPromotes browning; fond is visible and easy to judge.Can roast evenly when well made, though dark surfaces may brown food differently.A
Pan gravy and stovetop useUsually well suited to burner use and scraping up browned bits; check manufacturer guidance.Many models are not intended for direct burner heat or metal-tool scraping; verify instructions.A
Food releaseFood may stick, especially sugary glazes or dried-on drippings.Coating helps food and residue release.B
CleanupCan require soaking and more scrubbing.Generally faster to wash after use.B
Durability and careNo coating to wear; handles utensils and regular use well.Coating can scratch or wear; use gentler tools and follow care instructions.A
Price and long-term valueOften costs more than basic nonstick, but can last for many seasons.Often cheaper upfront; replacement may be needed if coating deteriorates.Depends
VersatilityUseful for roasting, gravy, and other oven-to-stove cooking.Good for roasting and easy-release cooking, with more limits on stovetop tasks.A

EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless Steel Roasting Pan Set with V-Shaped and Flat Racks

EWFEN 17 × 13-Inch Stainless Steel Roasting Pan Set with V-Shaped and Flat Racks
OUR VERDICT
Best Overall for Rack Flexibility
VIEW ON AMAZON

Thanksgiving cooking rarely follows a single setup: one roast may need to sit above its drippings, while another dish benefits from a flat support or the pan itself. The EWFEN set includes both a V-shaped rack and a flat rack, giving it more flexibility than the single-rack KITESSENSU and Glad. Its stainless steel pan has a 3.5-inch depth, useful when we want to contain juices or use the pan for a layered dish after the roast comes out.The main tradeoff is its footprint. At a listed 17 × 13-inch baking area, this is a substantial piece to store, and we should check oven clearance and dimensions before Thanksgiving day. Its fixed handles simplify lifting, but the product description’s nonstick wording refers to a polished stainless steel finish rather than a specified separate nonstick coating. We should not expect the same food-release behavior as the carbon steel KITESSENSU or Glad, and stainless steel cleanup may take more attention. For a household that values adaptable rack arrangements and a pan that can do more than hold a turkey, EWFEN is the strongest all-around match.

Pros:

  • Includes both V-shaped and flat racks for different roasting setups.
  • 3.5-inch depth helps contain drippings and supports layered dishes.
  • Fixed stainless steel handles provide integrated lifting points.
  • Pan can serve for dishes such as lasagna and vegetables as well as roasting.

Cons:

  • Large footprint can be difficult to store and may challenge a crowded oven.
  • Polished stainless steel is not a clearly specified separate nonstick coating.

Best for: Cooks who want two rack configurations and a deeper pan for roasting, drippings, and occasional side dishes.

Not ideal for: Anyone short on storage space or specifically seeking a clearly specified nonstick coating for easy food release.

Material:
Stainless steel
Pan baking area:
17 × 13 inches
Pan depth:
3.5 inches
Set contents:
Roasting pan, V-shaped rack, flat rack
Number of pieces:
3
Shape:
Rectangular

Bottom line: We rank EWFEN first for Thanksgiving versatility because its two racks and deeper pan cover more cooking setups than either single-rack alternative.

Our verdict
“We rank EWFEN first for Thanksgiving versatility because its two racks and deeper pan cover more cooking setups than either single-rack alternative.”

KITESSENSU Nonstick Turkey Roasting Pan with Rack, 17 x 14 Inch

KITESSENSU Nonstick Turkey Roasting Pan with Rack, 17 x 14 Inch
OUR VERDICT
Best for a Large Turkey and Easier Cleanup
VIEW ON AMAZON

When the centerpiece is a large turkey, the KITESSENSU makes its case with a 17 × 14-inch pan and stated 24-pound capacity. That listed capacity gives us a useful planning point that the other two options do not provide. The U-shaped rack lifts the bird above its juices, and the wide, riveted handles are designed to make a heavy pan easier to grip. Compared with the EWFEN, it trades a second rack and stainless steel construction for a nonstick carbon steel surface and an explicit capacity figure.That scale comes with practical constraints: the pan needs generous oven clearance and storage space, so we should measure before committing. Its nonstick finish and dishwasher-safe care are appealing when cleanup follows a long meal, though the listing does not give the same oven-temperature ceiling detail as Glad. We should follow the care and use instructions rather than infer compatibility beyond what is specified. The KITESSENSU is the straightforward pick for cooks prioritizing room for a large bird and a single elevated rack; those wanting a second setup for vegetables or other dishes may find EWFEN more adaptable, while cooks with small ovens should look to Glad.

Pros:

  • Stated capacity of 24 pounds helps with large-turkey planning.
  • U-shaped rack raises the roast above drippings.
  • Wide riveted handles are designed for a secure grip.
  • Nonstick finish and dishwasher-safe care support simpler cleanup.

Cons:

  • The 17 × 14-inch footprint needs substantial oven and storage space.
  • Includes one rack, offering less setup flexibility than the EWFEN set.
  • Listed maximum temperature is 450°F, lower than the Glad pan’s stated oven limit.

Best for: Hosts planning a large turkey who have enough oven clearance and want a nonstick pan with a stated capacity.

Not ideal for: Cooks with compact ovens or limited storage, or anyone wanting multiple rack configurations.

Material:
Carbon steel
Dimensions:
17 × 14 × 3.8 inches
Stated capacity:
24 pounds
Maximum temperature:
450°F
Rack:
U-shaped rack
Finish:
Nonstick

Bottom line: We recommend KITESSENSU when large-bird capacity and cleanup matter more than compact storage or multiple rack options.

Our verdict
“We recommend KITESSENSU when large-bird capacity and cleanup matter more than compact storage or multiple rack options.”

Glad Nonstick Roasting Pan with Rack, 15 x 10.3 Inches

Glad Nonstick Roasting Pan with Rack, 15 x 10.3 Inches
OUR VERDICT
Best Compact Pick
VIEW ON AMAZON

For a smaller oven, a second roast, or a more modest holiday meal, the Glad is the easiest pan in this lineup to accommodate. Its 15 × 10.3-inch footprint is notably smaller than the EWFEN and KITESSENSU, and the V-shaped rack raises meat to promote airflow. Carbon steel and a nonstick coating make this a simpler, more compact setup than EWFEN’s stainless steel set, although we give up the option of switching between two racks.The tradeoff is capacity and versatility. At 2.8 inches deep, it offers less room for drippings than the deeper EWFEN and KITESSENSU pans, and no turkey weight capacity is specified. Its oven-safe limit is clearly listed at 464°F, but it is not broiler safe or suitable for stovetop or open-flame use. That rules out some common finishing and gravy-making approaches; the other listings do not establish those uses either, so we should check manufacturer guidance before trying them. The coating also calls for care: avoid abrasive cleaners and metal utensils. We’d choose Glad for a tighter kitchen and routine oven roasting, not for a large gathering or a pan expected to move from oven to stovetop.

Pros:

  • Smaller 15 × 10.3-inch footprint is easier to fit and store.
  • V-shaped iron rack promotes airflow around the roast.
  • Nonstick coating supports food release and cleanup.
  • Oven safe up to 464°F and dishwasher safe.

Cons:

  • 2.8-inch depth and unspecified capacity make it less suited to a large turkey.
  • Not broiler safe or suitable for stovetop or open-flame use.
  • Care guidance advises against abrasive cleaners and metal utensils.

Best for: Cooks with limited oven or cabinet space who roast smaller portions and value nonstick release.

Not ideal for: Hosts roasting a large turkey, or cooks who need a broiler-safe pan or want to make gravy directly on the stovetop.

Material:
Carbon steel
Dimensions:
15 × 10.3 × 2.8 inches, excluding handles
Weight:
3.2 pounds
Maximum oven temperature:
464°F (240°C)
Rack:
V-shaped iron rack
Care:
Dishwasher safe

Bottom line: Glad is the practical compact choice when kitchen space matters more than large-bird capacity or finishing flexibility.

Our verdict
“Glad is the practical compact choice when kitchen space matters more than large-bird capacity or finishing flexibility.”

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Key Differences

The biggest practical difference appears when you make gravy. Stainless steel usually lets browned bits collect on the pan surface, and many models can go directly onto a burner so you can loosen those bits with liquid. That supports a more direct route from roast to gravy. Nonstick makes the turkey and residue easier to lift, but its coating may limit burner use and scraping. Follow the specific pan’s instructions: not every stainless pan is stovetop safe, and nonstick products vary.

For cleanup and care, the advantage reverses. Nonstick usually needs less effort to release stuck-on food, but its surface calls for nonmetal utensils and gentle cleaning. Stainless steel can take more scrubbing, yet there is no coating to protect from scratches. If you roast only once or twice a year and hate washing a large pan, nonstick’s convenience may be worth more than its reduced lifespan. For frequent cooks who value gravy and a pan they can use in several ways, stainless steel is the better long-term buy.

Construction matters as much as the label. A flimsy pan can warp or handle a heavy bird poorly, whether its interior is coated or bare. Before buying, check the pan’s dimensions, weight, handle security, rack fit, oven rating, and whether the manufacturer permits stovetop use. A well-built pan in the right size is more useful than a feature-rich one that cannot safely accommodate your turkey.

Detailed Comparison

Turkey browning (Stainless steel roasting pan wins — moderate)

Stainless steel wins by a moderate margin for control. Its surface makes browned drippings easy to see and can build flavorful fond for gravy. Nonstick can roast a turkey well too, but its surface changes how residue behaves, and darker finishes may affect how quickly food browns. For the bird itself, oven temperature, airflow, and pan fit remain major factors.

Pan gravy and stovetop use (Stainless steel roasting pan wins — major)

Stainless steel wins by a major margin, provided the pan is rated for burners. Many stainless models can go from oven to stovetop, allowing you to deglaze the pan and build gravy in the same vessel. A nonstick coating may not be designed for direct burner heat or scraping with a whisk. Check each model’s instructions before using it on the stove.

Food release (Nonstick roasting pan wins — moderate)

Nonstick wins by a moderate margin. Its coating helps turkey parts and sticky residue lift away with less coaxing. Stainless steel can hold onto drippings, especially if they dry, so a soak may be needed. That sticking can support gravy-making, but it is a drawback when the goal is simply to serve and wash up.

Cleanup (Nonstick roasting pan wins — moderate)

Nonstick wins by a moderate margin for routine washing. Food generally releases more readily, which saves time after a large meal. Stainless steel is more forgiving about scrubbing tools but may demand more work on baked-on residue. Neither pan should be left with grease or food residue for an extended period, and care directions differ by model.

Durability and care (Stainless steel roasting pan wins — major)

Stainless steel wins by a major margin for resistance to wear. It has no nonstick layer to scratch or lose effectiveness, and it tolerates metal utensils better. Nonstick needs gentler tools and cleaning; the coating’s lifespan depends on construction and care. For a pan expected to handle many holiday seasons, stainless steel is the safer bet.

Price and long-term value (moderate difference)

This is a close call that depends on how often you cook. Basic nonstick pans often cost less upfront, so they suit an occasional Thanksgiving cook who prioritizes convenience. Stainless steel can justify a higher initial price if you will use it regularly for roasts and gravy and keep it for years. The least expensive pan is not good value if it is too small or unstable for a heavy turkey.

Versatility (Stainless steel roasting pan wins — moderate)

Stainless steel wins by a moderate margin. A stovetop-safe model can roast, hold drippings, and support gravy-making in one pan, and it is better suited to utensils that might damage a coating. Nonstick remains useful for roasting when easy release is the priority, but its surface and heat limits can restrict other tasks.

Stainless steel roasting pan: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Often suitable for oven-to-stovetop gravy-making when the model is rated for burners.
  • No coating to scratch or wear away.
  • Handles metal tools and regular use well.
  • Good long-term value for frequent roasting.

Cons:

  • Food and drippings can stick, making cleanup slower.
  • May cost more upfront than an entry-level nonstick pan.
  • Quality and burner compatibility vary; confirm the manufacturer’s specifications.

Nonstick roasting pan: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Food and sticky residue tend to release more easily.
  • Usually faster to clean after the meal.
  • Often less expensive upfront.
  • A practical fit for occasional roasting when convenience is the priority.

Cons:

  • Coating can scratch or lose effectiveness with wear.
  • Requires gentler utensils and care.
  • Some models are unsuitable for direct stovetop use or scraping up fond.
  • May need replacement sooner than an uncoated pan.

Who Should Choose What

Choose Stainless steel roasting pan if:

  • You make pan gravy from turkey drippings and want to use the roasting pan on a burner.
  • You roast throughout the year and want one pan for repeated use.
  • You value resistance to scratches and a longer service life more than effortless release.

Choose Nonstick roasting pan if:

  • You roast mainly for Thanksgiving and want the quickest cleanup.
  • You often cook foods that stick and prefer easier release.
  • You are willing to use gentle utensils and replace the pan if its coating wears.

Skip both if: Skip both until you find a sturdy pan with enough capacity for your turkey, secure handles, a suitable rack, and heat ratings that match your cooking method.

Value for Money

Pay more for stainless steel if you will use the pan several times a year, make gravy in it, or keep it for many seasons. Its higher upfront cost buys durability and more cooking options, so it is better value for an active home cook. A cheaper nonstick pan can be the better value for someone who roasts occasionally and places a high price on quick cleanup. Its lower cost makes less sense if the coating is likely to be damaged or the pan cannot handle the gravy-making method you prefer.

Final Verdict

For most Thanksgiving cooks who want one roasting pan to last and make gravy, choose stainless steel, ideally a sturdy model explicitly rated for stovetop use. Its durability and oven-to-stove versatility outweigh the extra cleanup. Choose nonstick if this is an occasional-use pan and easier food release is your main priority; handle it gently and follow its care instructions. The deciding factor is whether you value a faster wash after dinner or a more durable pan that can take you from roasting to gravy.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is stainless steel or nonstick better for roasting a Thanksgiving turkey?

Both can roast a turkey successfully if the pan is sturdy, large enough, and used according to its heat rating. Stainless steel is the stronger all-purpose pick if you also want to brown drippings and make gravy. Nonstick is appealing when easy release and cleanup matter most.

Can I make gravy in a nonstick roasting pan?

That depends on the model. Some nonstick pans are not designed for direct burner heat, and metal tools can damage the coating. Check the manufacturer’s instructions before placing the pan on a stovetop. If the pan is not rated for that use, transfer the drippings to a suitable saucepan.

Is a more expensive stainless steel pan worth it?

It can be if you roast often, want a durable pan, and will use it for gravy or other oven-to-stove cooking. For one holiday meal a year, a well-made nonstick pan may offer better value if its lower effort and price matter more to you.

What should I check before buying a Thanksgiving roasting pan?

Check interior dimensions and capacity, pan weight, handle security, rack fit, oven rating, and stovetop compatibility. A pan should fit the turkey without crowding and remain manageable when full. Material alone does not make an undersized or flimsy pan a good choice.

You May Also Like

Why Brand Positioning Matters in Home Categories

Finding the right brand positioning in home categories is crucial because it directly influences how your audience perceives your value and…

The Espresso Machine Question: Is It Time to Upgrade from the Moka?

A moka pot makes different coffee than an espresso machine, not worse coffee. Here’s how to decide if upgrading fits your taste, budget, and routine.

How to Decide Between Investing and Saving on Home Purchases

Navigating whether to save or invest for your home depends on your goals and risk tolerance, and understanding these factors is essential before making a decision.

Price Drop Protection: How It Works

Keen shoppers need to understand how price drop protection works to save money—discover the key steps to maximize your refunds and avoid common pitfalls.