The best alternative spreads depend on whether you want a chocolate-hazelnut substitute, a nut-free option, or a sweeter treat for toast and snacks. My best overall pick is Pyure Keto Hazelnut Chocolate Spread for shoppers seeking a vegan, lower-sugar chocolate option; SunButter Original stands out for nut-free households, while Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter suits those who want a cookie-inspired spread. The main tradeoffs are sweetness and texture, ingredient preferences, and whether a spread must meet a specific dietary need. Some picks prioritize familiar dessert flavor, while others offer seed-based or soy-based alternatives. Read on for the full breakdown and help matching a jar to your kitchen.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
The lineup splits into distinct jobs: chocolate-hazelnut spreads satisfy a familiar sweet craving, while SunButter and WOWBUTTER offer options for shoppers avoiding peanuts or tree nuts.
Lower sugar changes the flavor brief: Pyure and ChocZero are geared toward shoppers limiting sugar, while cookie butters such as Lotus Biscoff are more clearly dessert-style choices.
Texture can matter as much as flavor: ChocZero‘s crunchy speculoos option adds cookie pieces, unlike the smoother spreads suited to an even layer on toast.
Ingredient preferences point to different picks: Date Lady uses dates for sweetness, Soom brings sesame tahini into the chocolate-spread category, and Earth Balance pairs peanut butter with flaxseed.
Package size is a use-frequency decision: the 26.5-ounce hazelnut cocoa spread and 35.3-ounce WOWBUTTER make more sense for regular household use than smaller jars meant for trying a flavor.
| Pyure Keto Hazelnut Chocolate Spread – Low Sugar Vegan Snack (13 oz) |  | Best Keto Hazelnut Chocolate Pick | Jar size: 13 oz | Net carbs: 2 g per serving | Ingredient count: 8 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| WOWBUTTER Creamy Soy Spread, 1.1 lb |  | Best Peanut-Free Sandwich Swap | Product type: Creamy soy spread | Weight: 1.1 lb | Protein: 7 g per 32 g serving | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Soom Chocolate Sesame Tahini Spread, 5g Protein, 12oz, 1 Pack |  | Best Short-Ingredient Chocolate Spread | Size: 12 oz | Protein: 5 g per serving | Sugar comparison: 67% less sugar than leading chocolate spreads | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ChocZero Sugar Free Crunchy Speculoos Cookie Butter, 12 oz Jar |  | Best Crunchy Cookie Butter Alternative | Jar size: 12 oz | Texture: Crunchy with cookie pieces | Fiber: 12 g prebiotic fiber per serving | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ChocZero Sugar-Free Dark Chocolate Hazelnut Spread, Vegan, 12 oz |  | Best High-Fiber Chocolate-Hazelnut Pick | Flavor: Dark chocolate hazelnut | Jar size: 12 oz | Net carbs: 1 g per serving | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, 26.5 oz |  | Best for a Classic Chocolate-Hazelnut Spread | Size: 26.5 oz jar | Flavor: Hazelnut with cocoa | Gluten-free: Yes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Date Lady Chocolate Date Spread – Organic, No Added Sugar |  | Best for No-Added-Sugar, Dairy-Free Ingredients | Ingredients: Organic dates, cocoa, coconut oil, cocoa butter, vanilla extract, sea salt | Added sugar: None | Dietary attributes: Vegan, non-GMO, gluten-free, dairy-free, paleo, kosher | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Earth Balance Creamy Peanut Butter and Flaxseed Spread, 16 oz |  | Best Protein-Packed Peanut Spread | Size: 16 oz | Texture: Creamy, no-stir | Protein: 7 g per serving | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SunButter Original Sunflower Seed Butter, Nut-Free Spread, 16 oz |  | Best Nut-Free Everyday Spread | Flavor: Original | Main ingredient: Roasted sunflower seeds | Package size: 16 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter Spread – Creamy, Non-GMO, Vegan (25.4 oz) |  | Best Dessert-Style Cookie Spread | Size: 25.4 oz, 1 jar | Texture: Smooth | Main ingredient: Finely crushed Lotus Biscoff biscuits | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Artisana Organic Hazelnut Cacao Spread, 8 Ounce |  | Best for a Simple Organic Hazelnut-Cacao Option | Flavor: Hazelnut cacao | Organic: Yes | Size: 8 ounces | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| WOWBUTTER Creamy Peanut-Free Soy Spread, 35.3 oz |  | Best for Peanut- and Tree Nut-Free Households | Net weight: 35.3 oz | Main ingredient: Whole toasted soy | Texture: Creamy | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Justin’s Chocolate Hazelnut Almond Butter Spread, 16 oz |  | Best No-Stir Chocolate Nut Butter | Size: 16 oz | Flavor: Chocolate hazelnut | Protein: 4g per serving | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Nocciolata Dark Dairy-Free Hazelnut Cocoa Spread – 8.82 oz (Made in Italy) |  | Best Dairy-Free Dark Cocoa Pick | Weight: 8.82 oz | Origin: Italy | Dietary attributes: Vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, organic | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Hazelnut Cocoa Spread, 12.3 oz |  | Best Everyday Organic Hazelnut Cocoa Spread | Brand: 365 by Whole Foods Market | Flavor: Hazelnut cocoa | Ingredients: Organic hazelnuts and cocoa | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| alternative spread | Dietary attributes | Flavor |
|---|---|---|
| Pyure Keto Hazelnut Chocolate | — | — |
| WOWBUTTER Creamy Soy Spread | Vegan, gluten-free, non-GMO | — |
| Soom Chocolate Sesame Tahini S | Dairy-free, gluten-free, vegan | — |
| ChocZero Sugar Free Crunchy Sp | — | — |
| ChocZero Sugar-Free Dark Choco | Sugar-free, vegan, keto-friendly, low-carb | Dark chocolate hazelnut |
| Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa | — | Hazelnut with cocoa |
| Date Lady Chocolate Date Sprea | Vegan, non-GMO, gluten-free, dairy-free, paleo, kosher | — |
| Earth Balance Creamy Peanut Bu | Vegan and gluten-free | — |
| SunButter Original Sunflower S | Vegan, kosher certified, Non-GMO Project Verified | Original |
| Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter Sp | Vegan and non-GMO | Caramelised biscuit |
| Artisana Organic Hazelnut Caca | — | Hazelnut cacao |
| WOWBUTTER Creamy Peanut-Free S | Vegan, non-GMO, kosher, halal | — |
| Justin’s Chocolate Hazelnut Al | — | Chocolate hazelnut |
| Nocciolata Dark Dairy-Free Haz | Vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, organic | Dark hazelnut cocoa |
| 365 by Whole Foods Market Orga | — | Hazelnut cocoa |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Pyure Keto Hazelnut Chocolate Spread – Low Sugar Vegan Snack (13 oz)
Pyure is the clearest fit for keto-minded shoppers who still want a familiar hazelnut-and-chocolate pairing: it lists just 2 g net carbs per serving and uses Oregon-grown hazelnuts. Its eight-ingredient formula is shorter than the supplied descriptions for many conventional-style spreads, while vegan, dairy-free, gluten-free, and peanut-free attributes widen its appeal. Compared with ChocZero Sugar-Free Dark Chocolate Hazelnut Spread, Pyure gives a higher stated net-carb count, but the available details highlight its short ingredient list rather than ChocZero’s prebiotic fiber and absence of sugar alcohols. The tradeoff is a flavor that may be less sweet than familiar chocolate-hazelnut spreads, plus only one listed jar size. I’d choose it for lower-carb versatility across toast, smoothies, and baking, not for an exact traditional-spread imitation.
Pros:- Lists 2 g net carbs per serving, a useful fit for shoppers tracking carbohydrates
- Made with Oregon-grown hazelnuts and eight ingredients
- Vegan, dairy-free, gluten-free, peanut-free, and non-GMO
- Smooth texture suits spreading, spooning, smoothies, and baking
Cons:- May taste less sweet than traditional chocolate-hazelnut spreads
- Only a 13 oz jar size is listed
Best for: Keto-focused shoppers seeking a vegan hazelnut chocolate spread with a stated 2 g net carbs per serving and a short ingredient list
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a very sweet, traditional chocolate-hazelnut taste or a choice of jar sizes
- Jar size:13 oz
- Net carbs:2 g per serving
- Ingredient count:8
- Hazelnut source:Oregon-grown
- Vegan:Yes
- Dairy-free:Yes
- Gluten-free:Yes
- Peanut-free:Yes
- Non-GMO:Yes
Our verdict“Choose Pyure if you want a short-ingredient, vegan hazelnut chocolate spread with a stated 2 g net carbs per serving and can accept a less-sweet flavor.”
WOWBUTTER Creamy Soy Spread, 1.1 lb
WOWBUTTER is the lineup’s practical peanut-butter-style choice, built for sandwiches, snacks, and dipping rather than a chocolate-dessert flavor. Its creamy soy base provides 7 g of complete protein per 32 g serving and 1,000 mg of omega-3, giving lunchbox buyers more nutritional detail than the supplied descriptions for spreads such as Soom Chocolate Sesame Tahini Spread. The manufacturer describes its facility as free of peanuts, tree nuts, gluten, dairy, and eggs, a useful distinction for households managing several food exclusions; anyone with an allergy should still check the package and their own safety requirements. Compared with Soom’s three-ingredient chocolate-and-tahini approach, WOWBUTTER is better suited to familiar savory-sweet sandwich use, but it contains soy. I’d skip it if soy is an avoid ingredient or if you want a dessert-style spread.
Pros:- Peanut-free soy spread designed for sandwiches, snacks, and dipping
- Provides 7 g complete protein and 1,000 mg omega-3 per 32 g serving
- Facility is described as free of peanuts, tree nuts, gluten, dairy, and eggs
- Vegan, non-GMO, kosher, and halal
Cons:- Soy makes it unsuitable for people avoiding soy
- Its peanut-butter-like profile is less suited to shoppers seeking a sweet chocolate spread
Best for: Families seeking a creamy peanut-free sandwich spread with stated protein and omega-3 amounts and facility allergen information
Not ideal for: People avoiding soy or shoppers looking for a chocolate, cookie-butter, or dessert-style spread
- Product type:Creamy soy spread
- Weight:1.1 lb
- Protein:7 g per 32 g serving
- Omega-3:1,000 mg per 32 g serving
- Dietary attributes:Vegan, gluten-free, non-GMO
- Facility information:Peanut-free, tree nut-free, gluten-free, dairy-free, egg-free
- Certifications:Kosher and halal
Our verdict“Pick WOWBUTTER for peanut-free sandwich routines when soy works for your household and a chocolate-style flavor is not the goal.”
Soom Chocolate Sesame Tahini Spread, 5g Protein, 12oz, 1 Pack
Soom takes chocolate spread in a sesame-forward direction: tahini, cane sugar, and cocoa powder are its three listed ingredients. That simple formula sets it apart from Pyure Keto Hazelnut Chocolate Spread, which is hazelnut-based and more explicitly positioned around low net carbs, while Soom offers a stated 5 g of plant protein per serving and 67% less sugar than leading chocolate spreads. Its nut-free, peanut-free, dairy-free, gluten-free, vegan, and kosher attributes may suit households looking beyond the usual hazelnut base. The tradeoff is that sesame has a distinct flavor, so this is not the closest match for a classic chocolate-hazelnut spread. It also has fewer flavor options listed, and the supplied product information flags specialty ingredients as a possible reason some buyers may find it costly. I’d choose it for a concise ingredient list, not for flavor variety.
Pros:- Made with three listed ingredients: tahini, cane sugar, and cocoa powder
- Provides 5 g of plant protein per serving
- Described as having 67% less sugar than leading chocolate spreads
- Vegan, nut-free, peanut-free, dairy-free, gluten-free, and kosher
Cons:- Sesame brings a distinct flavor that may not suit fans of classic hazelnut chocolate spreads
- Fewer flavor options are listed than for more familiar spread styles
- Specialty ingredients may make it a less appealing choice for shoppers prioritizing a basic spread
Best for: Shoppers who want a vegan chocolate spread with three listed ingredients, sesame tahini, and a stated 5 g of plant protein per serving
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking hazelnut flavor, multiple flavor choices, or a product positioned primarily around keto net carbs
- Size:12 oz
- Protein:5 g per serving
- Sugar comparison:67% less sugar than leading chocolate spreads
- Ingredients:Tahini, pure cane sugar, cocoa powder
- Nut-free:Yes
- Peanut-free:Yes
- Dietary attributes:Dairy-free, gluten-free, vegan
- Kosher:Yes
Our verdict“Choose Soom if you want a simple-ingredient, sesame-based chocolate spread with plant protein, rather than a hazelnut or keto-first alternative.”
ChocZero Sugar Free Crunchy Speculoos Cookie Butter, 12 oz Jar
ChocZero’s crunchy speculoos spread is the choice for cookie-butter fans who want a spiced, textured alternative to smooth chocolate and nut spreads. It lists 0 g sugar, uses monk fruit, and provides 12 g of prebiotic fiber per serving, so its appeal differs from ChocZero Sugar-Free Dark Chocolate Hazelnut Spread: this jar brings cookie pieces and spice rather than a smooth cocoa-and-hazelnut profile. That crunch makes it more distinctive on toast or in baking, though it may be less versatile for anyone who prefers an even texture. The sugar-free and keto-friendly positioning will interest low-carb shoppers, but the monk fruit sweetness may not resemble the familiar taste of sugar-based cookie butter. I’d pick this for texture and speculoos character, not as a close substitute for a classic hazelnut chocolate spread.
Pros:- Crunchy cookie pieces add texture to toast and baked treats
- Lists 0 g sugar and is described as keto-friendly
- Provides 12 g of prebiotic fiber per serving
- Monk fruit sweetener and gluten-free positioning
Cons:- Monk fruit may taste less sweet or different from sugar-based cookie butter
- Crunchy texture will not suit buyers who want a smooth spread
- Its spiced cookie profile is less like a conventional chocolate-hazelnut alternative
Best for: Low-carb shoppers who enjoy spiced cookie-butter flavor and want crunchy pieces for spreading or baking
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer smooth chocolate-hazelnut spreads, a traditional sugar-sweetened taste, or a uniform texture
- Jar size:12 oz
- Texture:Crunchy with cookie pieces
- Fiber:12 g prebiotic fiber per serving
- Sugar:0 g
- Sweetener:Monk fruit
- Gluten-free:Yes
- Keto-friendly:Yes
Our verdict“Choose this ChocZero jar if crunchy, spiced cookie butter matters more to you than a smooth chocolate-hazelnut flavor.”
ChocZero Sugar-Free Dark Chocolate Hazelnut Spread, Vegan, 12 oz
This ChocZero spread keeps the hazelnut-and-dark-chocolate pairing while aiming at shoppers limiting sugar and net carbs. The supplied details list 1 g net carb and 18 g prebiotic fiber per serving, along with monk fruit sweetening and no sugar alcohols. Against Pyure Keto Hazelnut Chocolate Spread, it offers a lower stated net-carb figure and more fiber, while Pyure highlights Oregon-grown hazelnuts and an eight-ingredient formula. The available information does not give a full nutrition panel or ingredient count for ChocZero, so buyers who need more detail should check the package before choosing. Its smooth format suits toast, pancakes, fruit, and desserts, but the prominent fiber figure may not be a selling point for everyone. I’d put it ahead for low-carb shoppers prioritizing fiber, rather than those seeking a fully detailed nutrition profile.
Pros:- Lists 1 g net carb per serving
- Provides 18 g of prebiotic fiber per serving
- Vegan and sweetened with monk fruit
- Contains no sugar alcohols and suits use on toast, fruit, pancakes, and desserts
Cons:- The available description gives limited nutrition details beyond fiber and net carbs
- The stated high fiber content may not appeal to every shopper
- Only a 12 oz jar size is listed
Best for: Vegan, low-carb shoppers who want a smooth dark chocolate-hazelnut spread and value the listed prebiotic fiber
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a full nutrition breakdown in the supplied product details or prefer a short, fully specified ingredient list
- Flavor:Dark chocolate hazelnut
- Jar size:12 oz
- Net carbs:1 g per serving
- Prebiotic fiber:18 g per serving
- Sweetener:Monk fruit
- Sugar alcohols:None
- Dietary attributes:Sugar-free, vegan, keto-friendly, low-carb
Our verdict“Pick ChocZero if you want a vegan chocolate-hazelnut spread with 1 g net carb and 18 g prebiotic fiber per serving, and will check the package for fuller nutrition details.”
Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, 26.5 oz
This is the straightforward pick for anyone who wants an indulgent cocoa-and-hazelnut flavor in a generously sized jar. Its 26.5-ounce format suits frequent toast, pancake, or baking use better than the smaller Date Lady Chocolate Date Spread, though the two serve different tastes: this leans on familiar creamy chocolate-nut richness, while Date Lady gets its sweetness from dates and has no added sugar. The larger jar also makes it a practical pantry staple if you share spreads at home. The tradeoff is its allergen profile: it contains hazelnuts and milk and may contain other tree nuts, so it is a poor fit for many allergy-conscious households. It is also a less suitable choice for shoppers seeking a dairy-free or less dessert-like alternative.
Pros:- Rich cocoa-hazelnut flavor suits both spreading and baking
- 26.5-ounce jar offers a larger pantry supply than Date Lady’s date-based spread
- Gluten-free formulation
- Versatile for toast, pancakes, and dessert recipes
Cons:- Contains hazelnuts and milk, with possible exposure to other tree nuts
- Does not fit dairy-free or nut-free diets
- Its rich, sweet profile may not suit shoppers seeking a savory or lower-sugar spread
Best for: Households that regularly use chocolate-hazelnut spread on toast, pancakes, or in baking and can safely eat hazelnuts and milk.
Not ideal for: People avoiding dairy or tree nuts, and shoppers seeking a no-added-sugar spread rather than a sweet chocolate treat.
- Size:26.5 oz jar
- Flavor:Hazelnut with cocoa
- Gluten-free:Yes
- Contains:Hazelnut and milk
- May contain:Other tree nuts
- Uses:Spreading and baking
Our verdict“Choose this large jar if you want familiar chocolate-hazelnut indulgence and have no concern about its milk and tree-nut allergens.”
Date Lady Chocolate Date Spread – Organic, No Added Sugar
Date Lady takes a different route from the hazelnut-cocoa spreads in this roundup: organic dates provide the sweetness, with cocoa, coconut oil, cocoa butter, vanilla, and sea salt rounding out the recipe. That makes it a useful option for vegan and dairy-free eaters who want a chocolate-style spread without added sugar or corn syrup. Compared with the Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, it avoids hazelnuts and milk, but it also gives up the familiar nutty richness and may feel thicker than a conventional chocolate spread. Its uses extend beyond toast: the product can sweeten coffee, stand in for frosting, or go into baking. The tradeoff is that date-based sweetness and texture will not appeal to everyone, especially those after a smooth, easy-spreading classic.
Pros:- No added sugar, dairy, corn syrup, or artificial flavors
- Organic, date-based recipe suits vegan and paleo dietary preferences
- Can be used on toast, in coffee, in baking, or as frosting
- BPA-free jar
Cons:- Thicker texture may be less convenient to spread than the Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa
- Date sweetness differs from the familiar flavor of conventional chocolate spreads
- Coconut oil and cocoa butter make it a distinct recipe, not a direct match for nut-butter spreads
Best for: Vegan or dairy-free shoppers who want an organic chocolate spread sweetened with dates and useful in both recipes and drinks.
Not ideal for: Buyers who expect a thin, silky hazelnut-chocolate texture or prefer the flavor of conventional added-sugar spreads.
- Ingredients:Organic dates, cocoa, coconut oil, cocoa butter, vanilla extract, sea salt
- Added sugar:None
- Dietary attributes:Vegan, non-GMO, gluten-free, dairy-free, paleo, kosher
- Artificial flavors:None
- Corn syrup:None
- Packaging:BPA-free jar
- Suggested uses:Toast, baking, coffee, sweetening, or frosting
Our verdict“Pick Date Lady if date-sweetened, dairy-free ingredients matter more to you than a classic silky hazelnut-chocolate texture.”
Earth Balance Creamy Peanut Butter and Flaxseed Spread, 16 oz
Earth Balance is the savory-leaning choice in this group: roasted peanuts and flaxseed make it a more filling alternative to sweet options such as Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter. It provides 7 grams of protein per serving, while agave syrup gives the peanut-and-flax mixture a touch of sweetness. The no-stir texture is convenient for quick sandwiches and snacks, avoiding the separation some natural nut and seed butters can require attention for. Compared with SunButter Original, it keeps the familiar peanut-butter profile but is not suitable for people avoiding peanuts. Flaxseed and expeller-pressed oils shape the blend, so this is not simply an unsweetened peanut-only spread. Its 16-ounce jar is a standard-sized option, but shoppers seeking a chocolate-style or strongly sweet dessert spread should look elsewhere.
Pros:- Provides 7 grams of protein per serving
- No-stir creamy texture is convenient for sandwiches and snacks
- Vegan and gluten-free
- Flaxseed adds a distinct ingredient profile compared with conventional peanut butter
Cons:- Contains peanuts, so it is unsuitable for people with peanut allergies
- Agave syrup adds sweetness that may not suit shoppers seeking an unsweetened spread
- Less dessert-oriented than Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter or chocolate spreads
Best for: Peanut-eating households looking for a creamy, no-stir sandwich spread with plant-based protein and a little sweetness.
Not ideal for: People with peanut allergies or those seeking a nut-free alternative, a chocolate spread, or a spread without added agave.
- Size:16 oz
- Texture:Creamy, no-stir
- Protein:7 g per serving
- Ingredients:Roasted peanuts, flaxseed, agave syrup, expeller-pressed oils
- Dietary attributes:Vegan and gluten-free
- Non-GMO:Non-GMO Project Verified
Our verdict“Choose Earth Balance for a convenient, protein-containing peanut spread if peanuts and agave both fit your diet.”
SunButter Original Sunflower Seed Butter, Nut-Free Spread, 16 oz
SunButter is the most useful fit here for people who need a spread without peanuts or tree nuts. Roasted sunflower seeds give it a smooth, creamy consistency and a savory seed flavor, making it more of a sandwich-and-snack staple than a dessert spread like Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter. It supplies 7 grams of plant-based protein and can also go into smoothies, sauces, and baking. Compared with Earth Balance Peanut Butter and Flaxseed Spread, SunButter avoids peanuts and several other listed allergens, though the flavor shifts from familiar peanut butter to roasted sunflower seed. That breadth is its strength, but buyers should still check the specific product packaging and household allergy guidance rather than assume every allergy risk is addressed. Its original flavor is also less suited to shoppers looking for a sweet chocolate alternative.
Pros:- Made from roasted sunflower seeds and free from peanuts and tree nuts
- Provides 7 grams of plant-based protein
- Works for sandwiches, smoothies, sauces, and baking
- Vegan, kosher certified, and Non-GMO Project Verified
Cons:- Roasted sunflower flavor differs from conventional peanut butter
- Original flavor is not a sweet or chocolate-style alternative
- Allergy-conscious buyers should still check the product label and household requirements
Best for: Families seeking a versatile peanut- and tree-nut-free spread for sandwiches, smoothies, and recipes.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who want a sweet, chocolate-forward spread or strongly prefer the taste of peanut butter.
- Flavor:Original
- Main ingredient:Roasted sunflower seeds
- Package size:16 oz
- Protein:7 g
- Dietary attributes:Vegan, kosher certified, Non-GMO Project Verified
- Allergen information:Free from peanuts, tree nuts, soy, dairy, gluten, eggs, sesame, fish, and shellfish
- Texture:Smooth and creamy
Our verdict“Choose SunButter when avoiding peanuts and tree nuts matters more than getting a sweet, nut-butter-style flavor.”
Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter Spread – Creamy, Non-GMO, Vegan (25.4 oz)
Lotus Biscoff is the pick for readers who want a dessert-like spread rather than a protein-oriented nut or seed butter. Made from finely crushed biscuits, it has a smooth, caramelised cookie flavor that works on toast and pancakes or as an ingredient in desserts. The 25.4-ounce jar is considerably larger than the 16-ounce Earth Balance and SunButter options, making it practical for frequent baking or sharing. It is vegan and non-GMO, and the description identifies a nut-free facility; unlike Date Lady Chocolate Date Spread, though, it is not positioned as a no-added-sugar choice. Its high sugar content is the central tradeoff, so it will not suit low-sugar diets or buyers seeking a savory, protein-forward spread. It also offers a very different flavor from chocolate-hazelnut alternatives.
Pros:- Smooth texture spreads easily on toast and pancakes
- Vegan and non-GMO
- No artificial colours, flavours, or preservatives
- Large 25.4-ounce jar suits regular dessert use and baking
Cons:- High sugar content makes it a poor fit for low-sugar diets
- Cookie-sweet flavor is less versatile for savory uses than SunButter
- Not a protein-focused substitute for peanut or seed butter
Best for: Vegan households and home bakers who want a large jar of smooth, caramelised cookie spread for toast and desserts.
Not ideal for: People limiting sugar or seeking a savory spread with the protein focus of Earth Balance or SunButter.
- Size:25.4 oz, 1 jar
- Texture:Smooth
- Main ingredient:Finely crushed Lotus Biscoff biscuits
- Flavor:Caramelised biscuit
- Dietary attributes:Vegan and non-GMO
- Palm oil:RSPO certified
- Artificial colours, flavours, or preservatives:None
- Facility:Nut-free facility
Our verdict“Choose Lotus Biscoff if you want a generous, vegan cookie spread for desserts and do not need a low-sugar or savory option.”
Artisana Organic Hazelnut Cacao Spread, 8 Ounce
Artisana keeps the choice focused: hazelnuts and cacao form the stated flavor profile, and the spread is organic. That makes it a fit for shoppers seeking a chocolate-hazelnut alternative without a long list of claims to sort through. Compared with Nocciolata Dark Dairy-Free Hazelnut Cocoa Spread, Artisana’s supplied details do not specify dairy-free, vegan, or palm-oil-free status, so buyers with those requirements should not assume it fits. Its 8-ounce jar is also smaller than the 12.3-ounce 365 Organic Hazelnut Cocoa Spread, which may suit someone trying a flavor rather than stocking up. The tradeoff is limited detail: no ingredient breakdown, nutrition facts, texture notes, or allergen information is provided here. Choose it for the organic hazelnut-cacao combination, not for dietary specifications that are not stated.
Pros:- Organic product designation
- Hazelnut-cacao flavor profile
- 8-ounce size is a manageable option for trying a spread
Cons:- Dietary and allergen information is not specified
- Ingredient and nutrition details beyond hazelnuts and cacao are not provided
- Smaller jar than 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Hazelnut Cocoa Spread
Best for: Shoppers who want an organic hazelnut-cacao spread in a modest-size jar and do not need unlisted dietary assurances.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need confirmed vegan, dairy-free, palm-oil-free, or allergen details, since those specifications are not provided.
- Flavor:Hazelnut cacao
- Organic:Yes
- Size:8 ounces
- Product type:Hazelnut spread
- Main flavor ingredients:Hazelnuts and cacao
- Dietary details:Not specified
Our verdict“Choose Artisana if an organic hazelnut-cacao profile and a smaller jar matter more than detailed dietary and nutrition specifications.”
WOWBUTTER Creamy Peanut-Free Soy Spread, 35.3 oz
WOWBUTTER fills a different need from the chocolate-hazelnut spreads in this roundup: it is a creamy soy-based alternative for people avoiding peanut and tree nuts. Made with whole toasted soybeans, it also supplies plant protein and naturally occurring omega-3 oils. The 35.3-ounce container is far larger than options such as Artisana Organic Hazelnut Cacao Spread, making it more suited to regular lunches and shared household use than occasional toast. The product is listed as vegan, non-GMO, kosher, and halal, and its peanut- and tree nut-free facility information may help families evaluating school-lunch options. Still, it contains soy, so it does not solve every allergen concern; people with soy restrictions should skip it. Its savory soy-butter role also differs from the dessert-like cocoa spreads, and the large container may be more than a light user needs.
Pros:- Made from whole toasted soybeans
- Peanut- and tree nut-free facility information is provided
- Vegan, non-GMO, kosher, and halal
- Large 35.3-ounce container suits frequent household use
Cons:- Contains soy, which rules it out for people avoiding soy
- Large container may be inconvenient for occasional users
- Creamy soy spread is not a direct substitute for a sweet cocoa spread
Best for: Families seeking a peanut- and tree nut-free sandwich spread for frequent lunches, provided soy is suitable for their household.
Not ideal for: People avoiding soy or shoppers seeking a sweet chocolate-hazelnut spread rather than a creamy seed-and-legume-style alternative.
- Net weight:35.3 oz
- Main ingredient:Whole toasted soy
- Texture:Creamy
- Dietary attributes:Vegan, non-GMO, kosher, halal
- Allergen information:Made in a peanut-free and tree nut-free facility
- Protein and oils:Contains plant protein and naturally occurring omega-3 oils
- Added ingredients:No added colors, flavors, preservatives, or hydrogenated oils
- Included extra:School lunch identification stickers
Our verdict“Pick WOWBUTTER for a large-format, peanut- and tree nut-free lunch spread if soy works for your dietary needs.”
Justin’s Chocolate Hazelnut Almond Butter Spread, 16 oz
Justin’s stands out for its no-stir recipe, a practical advantage for anyone who wants a ready-to-spread jar without mixing. Its chocolate-hazelnut profile includes almond butter and organic cocoa, so it brings a nut-butter angle that differs from Nocciolata Dark Dairy-Free Hazelnut Cocoa Spread, which is described as an intense-cocoa, dairy-free hazelnut option. The listed nutrition gives buyers more to work with than Artisana’s sparse details: each serving has 4g protein, 3g fiber, and 7g sugar. It is also gluten-free. The tradeoffs are meaningful: it contains palm oil, and 7g of sugar per serving may not suit shoppers limiting sweetness. The 16-ounce jar is larger than the 8-ounce Artisana option, but buyers prioritizing vegan or palm-oil-free claims should compare labels carefully rather than infer those attributes.
Pros:- No-stir recipe is ready to spread
- Gluten-free
- Made with organic cocoa
- Provides 4g protein and 3g fiber per serving
Cons:- Contains palm oil
- Has 7g sugar per serving
- Vegan status is not specified in the supplied product details
Best for: Chocolate-spread shoppers who want a no-stir nut-butter texture, gluten-free labeling, and stated protein and fiber per serving.
Not ideal for: People avoiding palm oil, limiting sugar, or seeking a product explicitly identified as vegan and palm-oil-free.
- Size:16 oz
- Flavor:Chocolate hazelnut
- Protein:4g per serving
- Fiber:3g per serving
- Sugar:7g per serving
- Cocoa:Organic
- Gluten-free:Yes
- Palm oil:RSPO-certified mass balance
- Recipe:No-stir
Our verdict“Choose Justin’s for a convenient no-stir chocolate nut butter with stated protein and fiber, but skip it if palm oil or sugar is a concern.”
Nocciolata Dark Dairy-Free Hazelnut Cocoa Spread – 8.82 oz (Made in Italy)
Nocciolata is the clearest choice here for a dairy-free, vegan dark-cocoa spread, with organic ingredients and no palm oil listed. Its intense cocoa profile gives it a more pronounced chocolate focus than 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Hazelnut Cocoa Spread, whose supplied description emphasizes a rich, creamy general-purpose spread rather than a dark style. The 8.82-ounce jar is compact, while the stated uses—from toast and fruit to pancakes and baking—make it adaptable beyond breakfast. Those dietary strengths come with a firm allergen caveat: it contains both hazelnuts and soy, so it is unsuitable for people who must avoid either. It is also a smaller jar than Justin’s 16-ounce option, and the provided details do not include nutrition figures. This pick makes most sense when dairy-free and palm-oil-free attributes matter more than volume or nutrition data.
Pros:- Dairy-free and vegan-friendly
- Made with organic ingredients
- Palm-oil-free
- Intense cocoa flavor and flexible uses for toast, fruit, pancakes, and baking
Cons:- Contains hazelnuts and soy
- 8.82-ounce jar is smaller than Justin’s 16-ounce option
- Nutrition figures are not provided in the supplied details
Best for: Vegan or dairy-free shoppers who want an organic, palm-oil-free spread with an intense cocoa flavor and several serving uses.
Not ideal for: Anyone avoiding hazelnuts or soy, or buyers who want a larger jar or stated nutrition information.
- Weight:8.82 oz
- Origin:Italy
- Dietary attributes:Vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, organic
- Allergens:Contains hazelnuts and soy
- Palm oil:None
- Flavor:Dark hazelnut cocoa
- Suggested uses:Toast, pancakes, waffles, crêpes, fruit, and baking
Our verdict“Choose Nocciolata when vegan, dairy-free, palm-oil-free ingredients and dark cocoa matter more than jar size or nutrition detail.”
365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Hazelnut Cocoa Spread, 12.3 oz
365 offers a straightforward everyday pick for shoppers who want an organic hazelnut-cocoa spread in a middle-size jar. The product details name organic hazelnuts and cocoa and state that it is free from artificial ingredients, while the description highlights a rich, creamy texture suited to toast, fruit, and baked goods. At 12.3 ounces, it holds more than Artisana’s 8-ounce jar without reaching the larger format of Justin’s 16-ounce spread. That balance can suit regular home use without committing to the 35.3-ounce WOWBUTTER container, though WOWBUTTER serves a different purpose as a peanut- and tree nut-free soy spread. The limitation is sparse specification detail: no nutrition figures, allergen statements, or vegan status are supplied. Choose 365 for the organic ingredients and versatility, not for dietary claims the listing does not establish.
Pros:- Made with organic hazelnuts and cocoa
- Free from artificial ingredients
- Rich, creamy texture is described as easy to spread
- 12.3-ounce size offers more than Artisana’s 8-ounce jar
Cons:- Allergen information is not provided
- Vegan status and nutrition figures are not specified
- Not presented as a peanut- or tree nut-free spread
Best for: Households wanting an organic hazelnut-cocoa spread for regular toast, fruit, and baking use in a moderate-size jar.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need confirmed allergen, vegan, or nutrition information, or shoppers seeking a peanut- and tree nut-free alternative.
- Brand:365 by Whole Foods Market
- Flavor:Hazelnut cocoa
- Ingredients:Organic hazelnuts and cocoa
- Size:12.3 oz
- Artificial ingredients:Free from
- Texture:Rich and creamy
- Suggested uses:Toast, fruit, and baked goods
Our verdict“Pick 365 for a versatile, moderate-size organic hazelnut-cocoa spread if you do not need dietary details absent from the listing.”
How We Picked
I compared the 15 spreads by the job a buyer is hiring them to do: replace a familiar nut spread, provide a dessert-like topping, or meet a dietary preference. The main criteria were flavor and texture cues, ingredient and sweetener approach, dietary fit, package size, and versatility for toast, fruit, baking, or snacks. I gave weight to how clearly each product serves a distinct need rather than treating all spreads as interchangeable.
The ranking puts the most broadly useful option first, then favors products with a clear advantage for a particular buyer. A lower-sugar or allergen-aware formula can rank well for that audience without being the best match for someone seeking classic cookie-butter sweetness. Larger jars can offer practical value for frequent use, but size alone does not outrank a better flavor or dietary fit. Since individual taste and allergy needs vary, I also note who may want to skip each style.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Alternative Spreads
Before choosing a jar, decide what you want to replace: a nut butter, a chocolate spread, or a sweet treat. These products differ in ways that affect everyday use, so I would match the spread to your household, preferred sweetness, and usual serving occasions rather than relying on the label alone.
Choose the Flavor Role Before the Ingredient
“Alternative spread” covers several different cravings, and the label does not tell you whether a product behaves like a pantry staple or a dessert topping. Chocolate-hazelnut styles aim for a familiar cocoa-and-nut profile, while cookie butters lean into sweet, spiced biscuit flavor. Seed and soy spreads are closer to nut-butter substitutes and may suit sandwiches or savory pairings better. A common mistake is buying a product for its ingredient claim when what you really want is a specific taste. Decide whether it needs to work on toast every morning or mainly as an occasional treat. That use case narrows the field faster than comparing jars by name alone.
Read Sweetener Claims in Context
“No added sugar” and “sugar-free” describe different formulation approaches, and neither guarantees that a spread tastes like a conventional chocolate spread. Date-sweetened products bring a different flavor and sweetness profile than options made with sugar substitutes. If you are choosing a reduced-sugar spread, check the ingredient and nutrition information on the package and consider how you plan to portion it. A highly sweet spread may work well as a thin topping but feel overpowering in a sandwich. Conversely, a less-sweet option may need fruit or another ingredient to round out a snack. Match the sweetener approach to your preference, not just the front-of-jar wording.
Check Allergy Suitability Beyond the Product Name
Soy, sunflower seed, sesame, peanuts, and tree nuts each create different allergy considerations. A “peanut-free” or “nut-free” product can be relevant for some households, but buyers with serious allergies should check the current package for allergen statements and cross-contact information. Recipes and manufacturing details can change, so an older product description is not a substitute for the label in hand. Also distinguish between avoiding peanuts and avoiding all legumes or seeds; those are not the same dietary requirement. If several people share a kitchen, consider how the spread will be stored and served to reduce accidental mixing. Choose based on the specific allergen concern rather than assuming all alternatives are interchangeable.
Think About Texture and Where You Will Use It
Smooth spreads are easier to spread evenly on bread and fold into recipes, while crunchy versions add texture without extra toppings. Thick or dense spreads may suit dipping fruit, but can be less convenient for a quick sandwich. For baking, check whether the product’s sweetness and consistency are likely to affect the recipe; a cookie butter will not behave exactly like plain nut butter. If you mainly want a topping, a distinctive flavor can matter more than versatility. For an all-purpose jar, prioritize a texture that works across toast, snacks, and simple recipes. This helps avoid buying a specialty spread that ends up used only once.
Match Jar Size to How Often You Will Use It
A larger jar may be practical for a household that already knows it likes the flavor, but it is a poor first purchase when the style is unfamiliar. Specialty spreads can be less versatile than everyday seed or soy butter, so a smaller package may reduce waste while you decide whether the taste fits your routine. Check the package size alongside how many people will share it and what meals it will support. Once a spread becomes a regular staple, a larger format can cut down on repeat shopping. Do not treat the biggest jar as the best value if you are unsure you will finish it. Frequency of use is the real measure of value at home.
Pay More for a Specific Benefit, Not a Broad Promise
A premium or specialty spread makes sense when its ingredient sourcing, dietary fit, or distinctive flavor solves a real need. If you simply want a sweet topping, a more specialized formula may not offer a meaningful advantage over a straightforward cookie butter or cocoa spread. Compare the ingredient list and intended use instead of assuming organic, imported, or specialty wording means better for every buyer. For a household managing a dietary restriction, a well-matched formula can be worth prioritizing over broad versatility. For casual use, familiar flavor and a manageable jar size may matter more. Spend on the attribute you will actually notice in each serving.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which spread should I choose if I want a lower-sugar chocolate option?
Start by comparing the ingredient lists and nutrition information for the sugar-free and lower-sugar chocolate options, since their sweetener approaches can affect flavor. Pyure is a strong first choice in this roundup for shoppers seeking a vegan, lower-sugar hazelnut-chocolate style. ChocZero’s dark chocolate hazelnut spread is another option to compare if you prefer a darker cocoa direction. If you are sensitive to particular sweeteners, check the package before buying rather than assuming every reduced-sugar formula will suit you. Taste preference matters here: the closest match to a conventional sweet spread may not be the one with the lowest sugar.
What should I buy for a household avoiding peanut and tree-nut spreads?
SunButter Original and WOWBUTTER are the clearest alternatives in this lineup for shoppers seeking sunflower- or soy-based spreads rather than conventional nut butter. They differ in their main ingredients, so choose according to your household’s preferences and any other dietary restrictions. “Nut-free” wording does not replace checking the current package for allergen and cross-contact information. This is especially important if the spread is for someone with a serious allergy. If sesame or soy is also a concern, check those ingredients too before selecting a jar.
Are cookie butter spreads a practical substitute for everyday nut butter?
Cookie butter can replace nut butter in some snack situations, but it is better understood as a sweet, dessert-style spread than as a like-for-like pantry substitute. Lotus Biscoff and ChocZero’s crunchy speculoos option emphasize cookie flavor, which may not suit savory sandwiches or recipes designed around plain nut butter. Their sweetness and texture can also make them less flexible for everyday use. If you want a spread for fruit, toast, and varied recipes, a seed- or soy-based option may be easier to use across meals. Pick cookie butter when its distinctive flavor is the point.
How do I choose between date-sweetened and sugar-free chocolate spreads?
Choose based on both your ingredient preferences and the taste you want, not solely on the wording of the sweetener claim. Date Lady’s chocolate date spread uses dates for its sweetness, which gives it a different profile from sugar-free options such as ChocZero. If you are limiting particular sugars or sweeteners for health reasons, review the full nutrition and ingredient information and follow advice from your health professional. If your goal is simply a less conventional ingredient list, the date-based option may be more appealing. Expect the flavor to differ from a standard chocolate-hazelnut spread.
Is it worth buying a large jar before I know whether I like the flavor?
For an unfamiliar style, a smaller jar is usually the safer way to learn whether its sweetness, texture, and flavor work for you. This matters most for distinctive options such as cookie butter, tahini chocolate spread, and specialty hazelnut blends, which may not replace an everyday spread in every household. Larger formats such as the 26.5-ounce hazelnut cocoa spread or 35.3-ounce WOWBUTTER make more sense when several people use them regularly. Check the package directions for storage and use after opening. Buy larger only when the spread has a clear place in your routine.
Conclusion
For the best overall fit, I recommend Pyure Keto Hazelnut Chocolate Spread to shoppers who want a vegan, lower-sugar chocolate option. For value through regular use, consider the larger-format hazelnut cocoa spread or WOWBUTTER, provided the flavor and ingredients suit your household. For a premium pick, Artisana Organic Hazelnut Cacao Spread is the one to explore if organic positioning and a specialty chocolate-hazelnut style are your priorities. For beginners, Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter offers a recognizable cookie-inspired flavor, though it is sweeter and less versatile than a seed butter. For specific needs, choose SunButter or WOWBUTTER for nut-avoidant households, Soom for a sesame-based chocolate option, or ChocZero when a sugar-free crunchy cookie-butter style appeals. Let your dietary requirements and intended use settle the choice before jar size or flavor novelty does.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
