TL;DR
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
A Good Housekeeping Test Kitchen guide argues the single biggest pizza upgrade is resting refrigerated dough for two to three hours at room temperature before shaping. During that passive rest, fermentation resumes and gluten relaxes, making the dough softer, more flavorful, and easier to stretch.
The most effective way to improve homemade pizza may require almost no effort, according to Good Housekeeping’s Test Kitchen: take refrigerated dough out two to three hours before baking and simply let it rest at room temperature. Food producer Tina Martinez, who has developed five pizza recipes for the magazine’s most recent issue, says this passive waiting period — not a new ingredient or technique — is what turns a cold, tight dough ball into one that is soft, stretchy, and ready for the oven.
The guidance centers on what happens inside the dough during fermentation. After mixing, dough goes into the refrigerator for an overnight rise of up to 72 hours, depending on the recipe. During that time, yeast consumes sugars in the flour and produces carbon dioxide, alcohol, and flavorful compounds. The carbon dioxide makes the dough rise, while the slow, cold fermentation builds more developed flavor than dough that is mixed, shaped, and baked immediately.
Fermentation continues after the dough leaves the refrigerator. As it warms, yeast becomes more active and gluten relaxes, which is why the three-hour rest before shaping matters: the dough becomes soft, slightly puffy, and easier to stretch. The flour also fully hydrates during resting, and the gluten network — which gives dough strength and elasticity — develops so the dough can hold its shape while remaining stretchable.
Martinez offers practical rules for the rest period. Divide the dough after taking it out of the refrigerator, shape portions into balls, and place them in lightly oiled, covered containers so the surface doesn’t dry out. Do not punch the dough down or re-knead it — the goal is warming and relaxing, not restarting the process. Dough is ready when it feels soft and supple, looks slightly puffy, and springs back slowly when pressed rather than snapping into place. If it resists stretching, cover it and wait another 15 to 20 minutes. When shaping, work from the center outward with your hands, leave the outer edge untouched for the crust, and avoid a rolling pin, which presses out fermentation bubbles.
Why the Waiting Period Changes Results
For home cooks, the advice lowers the barrier to better pizza without added cost or skill. The technique replaces active work with passive time: the cook does nothing but cover the dough and wait. According to Martinez, the payoff is twofold — better flavor from extended fermentation and better texture from relaxed gluten that stretches instead of snapping back.
The timing guidance also addresses a common failure point. Dough taken straight from the refrigerator is cold and tight, fights the cook during stretching, and shrinks repeatedly. Martinez’s guideline of two to three hours, adjusted for dough-ball size and kitchen temperature, gives cooks a practical benchmark: larger portions or cooler kitchens need more time; smaller portions in warmer rooms need less.
How the Tip Reached Readers
The guidance comes from the Good Housekeeping Test Kitchen, published as a how-to article on the magazine’s website. Martinez, the piece’s author, is the Test Kitchen’s food producer with more than 15 years of culinary experience in recipe development and food styling for print, digital, and television. She writes that the idea drew pushback when she explained it in a TikTok video — one viewer responded, “You lost me at three hours” — which prompted her to clarify that the rest requires no active work: the dough is simply removed from the refrigerator, covered, and left alone.
The article’s credibility rests on the Test Kitchen’s repeated testing of the method across the five pizza recipes Martinez developed for the magazine’s most recent issue.
“You lost me at three hours.”
— Reader response to Martinez’s TikTok video
Where Timing Remains Imprecise
The two-to-three-hour window is a guideline, not a fixed rule. Martinez notes the exact timing depends on the size of the dough balls and the kitchen’s temperature, so cooks must judge readiness by feel — soft, supple, and slowly springing back — rather than by the clock. The article does not specify resting times for particular dough weights, flour types, or hydration levels, and it does not address doughs stored longer than 72 hours or gluten-free alternatives. Readers with those recipes will need to adjust by observation.
Applying the Method at Home
Cooks trying the method can plan backward from baking time: remove the dough from the refrigerator, portion and cover it, and let it rest until soft and puffy. If the dough resists stretching, an additional 15-to-20-minute pause usually resolves it. Food-safety note: once shaped and topped, pizza should be baked thoroughly, and any leftover dough should be returned promptly to refrigeration and used within the storage window the recipe specifies.
Key Questions
Do I have to do anything during the three-hour rest?
No. According to Martinez, the only steps are taking the dough out of the refrigerator, covering it, and waiting. No kneading or punching down is needed — that would restart the process the rest is meant to finish.
Can I rest the dough for less than three hours?
Smaller dough portions in a warmer kitchen may need less time. The reliable test is feel: the dough should be soft, slightly puffy, and spring back slowly when gently pressed. If it shrinks while stretching, rest it another 15 to 20 minutes.
Why does cold dough fight back when I stretch it?
Cold dough has tight gluten that hasn’t relaxed. As the dough warms, the gluten loosens and the dough becomes easier to shape and less likely to snap back, according to the Good Housekeeping guide.
Should I use a rolling pin to shape the dough?
No. Martinez advises stretching by hand from the center outward, leaving the edge untouched for the crust. A rolling pin can press out the bubbles formed during fermentation.
How long can pizza dough stay in the refrigerator before use?
Depending on the recipe, dough can undergo an overnight rise of up to 72 hours in the refrigerator. Longer, slower fermentation develops more flavor than baking immediately after mixing.
Source: rss
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
