3 Best Holiday Spreads in 2027
AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

For holiday spreads that bring a distinct seasonal flavor to the table, I’d start with Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam for its tart-sweet fruit blend, Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves for baking and autumn-inspired breakfasts, and Nutella’s ornament pack for individual servings and cheerful gifting. They serve different purposes: a fruit-forward jam for brunch, a warmly spiced preserve in two full jars, and a familiar cocoa-hazelnut spread in seven mini jars.

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

My ranking favors serving flexibility, seasonal character, and package format. Stonewall Kitchen takes the lead because its pears, cranberries, raspberries, and orange liqueur give it a distinctive holiday profile that can move from toast to a brunch spread. Bonne Maman is the more practical choice for shoppers who want a larger supply and baking uses, while Nutella is the easiest to portion or share. The tradeoff is that the most festive options are also the most seasonal, and the mini jars offer less spread per serving than a standard jar.

3
compared
3
brands
2
flavors
Which holiday spread should you buy?
★ Top Pick
Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam
Best Overall — distinctive fruit flavor for holiday brunch
Pears, cranberries, and raspberries create a clear tart-sweet contrast.
See on Amazon →
Households that want two substantial jars for seasonal breakfasts, yogurt, and baking.
Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Pres
Pumpkin with cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove delivers a warm seasonal flavor.
View on Amazon →
Gift-givers and hosts who want individually portioned sweet spreads for holiday sharing.
Nutella Hazelnut Spread with C
Seven mini jars make portioning and sharing straightforward.
View on Amazon →
Pros & cons at a glance
Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam
✓ Pears, cranberries, and raspberries create a clear tart-sweet contrast.
✗ The holiday-focused flavor may feel less suitable outside the season.
Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Pres
✓ Pumpkin with cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove delivers a warm seasonal flavor.
✗ Contains sugar, which may not suit buyers seeking a less-sweet spread.
Nutella Hazelnut Spread with C
✓ Seven mini jars make portioning and sharing straightforward.
✗ Each mini jar is only 30 grams, making the pack less practical for frequent use.

Key Takeaways

  • Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam is my best overall pick for a holiday brunch table, balancing tart cranberries and raspberries with ripe pear and a hint of orange liqueur.
  • Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves gives buyers two 13-ounce glass jars, making it the strongest choice here for repeated breakfasts, yogurt, and seasonal baking.
  • Nutella’s seven-mini-jar ornament pack is the most shareable format, but its 30-gram portions are less practical for frequent, high-volume use.
  • For fruit-forward flavor, choose Stonewall Kitchen; for warm spice, choose Bonne Maman; for cocoa and hazelnut, choose Nutella.
  • All three products lean seasonal in flavor or packaging, so shoppers seeking a neutral spread for year-round use may prefer a different option.
2
Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Pres
Best for Versatility — two full jars for breakfast and baking
1
Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam
Best Overall — distinctive fruit flavor for holiday brunch
3
Nutella Hazelnut Spread with C
Best for Sharing — festive individual jars in a familiar flavor

Our Top Best Holiday Spreads Picks

Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam, 12.5 ozStonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam, 12.5 ozBest Overall — distinctive fruit flavor for holiday brunchProduct type: Holiday jamWeight: 12.5 ozFruit ingredients: Pears, cranberries, and raspberriesVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves, 13 oz Jars, Pack of 2Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves, 13 oz Jars, Pack of 2Best for Versatility — two full jars for breakfast and bakingFlavor: Pumpkin spicePack size: 2 jarsNet weight: 13 oz per jarVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, Holiday Ornament Pack, 7 Mini Jars, 7 ozNutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, Holiday Ornament Pack, 7 Mini Jars, 7 ozBest for Sharing — festive individual jars in a familiar flavorFlavor: Hazelnut with cocoaQuantity: 7 mini jarsJar size: 30 g eachVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Specs at a glance
holiday spreadFlavorPackagingSuggested uses
Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam———
Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice PresPumpkin spiceGlass jarsToast, yogurt, and baking
Nutella Hazelnut Spread with CHazelnut with cocoaFestive ornament packToast, pancakes, waffles, fruit, and baked goods

More Details on Our Top Picks

  1. Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam, 12.5 oz

    Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam, 12.5 oz

    Best Overall — distinctive fruit flavor for holiday brunch

    View Latest Price

    Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam earns my top spot because its fruit combination feels tailored to a festive table without limiting the spread to one serving idea. Pears provide a mellow base, cranberries bring tartness, raspberries add a sweeter berry note, and a hint of orange liqueur gives the blend a more layered holiday character. Compared with Bonne Maman’s cinnamon-and-clove profile, this is the better fit for someone who wants bright fruit rather than baking spice.

    The 12.5-ounce jar is suited to a brunch board, toast, or a host gift where a single seasonal jar feels considered rather than excessive. The description also points to holiday gifting, so this pick has a natural place in a small food gift alongside bread or breakfast treats. Its flavor contrast is the main draw: it can add a tart counterpoint to rich breakfast items, while the raspberry and pear keep it from tasting purely sharp.

    The limitation is its season-specific appeal. The name and festive fruit blend make it less neutral than an everyday preserve, and the single jar is not the lineup’s best choice for a household that wants a generous supply for repeated use. Bonne Maman provides two larger jars and a clearer route into baking, while Nutella gives hosts individual portions. I’d choose Stonewall Kitchen when flavor distinction and brunch presentation matter more than volume or everyday versatility.

    Pros:
    • Pears, cranberries, and raspberries create a clear tart-sweet contrast.
    • A hint of orange liqueur adds a more distinctive flavor than a straightforward berry jam.
    • Fits holiday brunch as well as seasonal gifting.
    • A 12.5-ounce jar is a manageable size for serving or giving.
    Cons:
    • The holiday-focused flavor may feel less suitable outside the season.
    • One jar provides less supply than Bonne Maman’s two-jar pack.

    Best for: Holiday hosts who want a fruit-forward spread for brunch, toast, or a modest seasonal food gift.

    Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking a neutral year-round preserve, a warm pumpkin-spice flavor, or multiple jars for frequent use.

    • Product type:Holiday jam
    • Weight:12.5 oz
    • Fruit ingredients:Pears, cranberries, and raspberries
    • Flavor note:Hint of orange liqueur
    • Suggested serving:Holiday brunch
    • Gift suitability:Described as suitable for host or holiday gifting
    Our verdict
    “I recommend Stonewall Kitchen as the most distinctive all-around holiday spread for buyers who want fruit-led flavor at brunch or in a seasonal gift.”
  2. Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves, 13 oz Jars, Pack of 2

    Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves, 13 oz Jars, Pack of 2

    Best for Versatility — two full jars for breakfast and baking

    View Latest Price

    Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves is my pick for buyers who expect to use a holiday spread beyond toast. Pumpkin, cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove give it a warm, recognizable seasonal profile, and the suggested uses include stirring it into yogurt or working it into baking. Compared with Stonewall Kitchen’s tart fruit blend, this is rounder and more spice-led; compared with Nutella’s mini jars, it is better suited to keeping a useful amount on hand.

    The pack contains two 13-ounce glass jars, which makes it the most substantial format in this lineup by total listed net weight. That can be useful when one jar is kept for breakfast and the other is reserved for recipes or sharing. The product description also specifies simple ingredients, with no high fructose corn syrup or artificial flavors, and lists Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, and kosher. These details may help shoppers looking for particular ingredient or dietary attributes, though buyers should check the package for their own needs.

    The tradeoff is the flavor itself. Pumpkin, cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove are a strong seasonal cue, not a neutral choice for every palate or every recipe. It also contains sugar, so it will not suit shoppers looking to avoid sweetened preserves. Compared with Stonewall Kitchen, it has less of a bright, tart fruit contrast; compared with Nutella, it has no individual portions for easy sharing. I’d choose this option when quantity and kitchen flexibility outrank a gift-ready mini format or a fruit-led brunch spread.

    Pros:
    • Pumpkin with cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove delivers a warm seasonal flavor.
    • Two 13-ounce jars offer more supply than the other listed packages.
    • Can be served on toast, stirred into yogurt, or used in baking.
    • Description lists no high fructose corn syrup or artificial flavors, plus stated dietary certifications.
    Cons:
    • Contains sugar, which may not suit buyers seeking a less-sweet spread.
    • Pumpkin spice is seasonal and may not appeal to every palate.
    • Two full-size jars are less convenient for individual portions than Nutella’s mini jars.

    Best for: Households that want two substantial jars for seasonal breakfasts, yogurt, and baking.

    Not ideal for: Buyers who dislike pumpkin spice, want a fruit-forward preserve, or are avoiding sugar.

    • Flavor:Pumpkin spice
    • Pack size:2 jars
    • Net weight:13 oz per jar
    • Ingredients:Pumpkin, sugar, pectin, lemon juice, and spices
    • Packaging:Glass jars
    • Origin:Made in France
    • Certifications:Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, and kosher
    • Suggested uses:Toast, yogurt, and baking
    Our verdict
    “I recommend Bonne Maman for buyers who want a warm seasonal flavor in a larger two-jar format that can serve both breakfast and baking.”
  3. Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, Holiday Ornament Pack, 7 Mini Jars, 7 oz

    Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, Holiday Ornament Pack, 7 Mini Jars, 7 oz

    Best for Sharing — festive individual jars in a familiar flavor

    View Latest Price

    Nutella’s holiday ornament pack stands apart from the preserves because its main advantage is how it is portioned and presented. Seven 30-gram mini jars provide individual servings of creamy hazelnut spread with cocoa, making them easy to set out for a group or include in seasonal gifting. Where Stonewall Kitchen is the more distinctive choice for a fruit-based brunch and Bonne Maman offers the most kitchen utility, Nutella is the simplest crowd-friendly option for toast, pancakes, waffles, fruit, and baked goods.

    The familiar cocoa-hazelnut flavor may make it an easier fit for guests who prefer a sweet, smooth spread to tart cranberries or pumpkin spice. The ornament-style packaging also gives this product a more overtly festive presentation than the two jars of Bonne Maman. For a holiday breakfast with different serving sizes, or a small gift that benefits from individual packaging, the seven-jar format has a clear purpose.

    That format brings a practical compromise: each jar holds just 30 grams, so this is not the choice I’d make for frequent or high-volume use. Buyers who want a jar to keep open for a household will get more practical supply from Bonne Maman’s two 13-ounce jars or Stonewall Kitchen’s single 12.5-ounce jar. The seasonal packaging may also be less appealing after the holidays. I’d rank Nutella third overall not because it lacks a useful role, but because portioning and presentation are more specialized advantages than the broader brunch and pantry uses offered by the other two picks.

    Pros:
    • Seven mini jars make portioning and sharing straightforward.
    • Creamy hazelnut spread with cocoa suits toast, pancakes, waffles, fruit, and baking.
    • Festive ornament packaging supports seasonal gifting.
    • The familiar flavor offers a contrast to the fruit and pumpkin-spice options.
    Cons:
    • Each mini jar is only 30 grams, making the pack less practical for frequent use.
    • Holiday-themed packaging is seasonal.
    • The individual-serving format provides less flexibility for recipes needing larger amounts.

    Best for: Gift-givers and hosts who want individually portioned sweet spreads for holiday sharing.

    Not ideal for: Households that use spread frequently, want full-size jars, or prefer tart fruit or pumpkin-spice flavors.

    • Flavor:Hazelnut with cocoa
    • Quantity:7 mini jars
    • Jar size:30 g each
    • Total weight:7 oz
    • Texture:Creamy and spreadable
    • Packaging:Festive ornament pack
    • Suggested uses:Toast, pancakes, waffles, fruit, and baked goods
    Our verdict
    “I recommend Nutella’s ornament pack when festive presentation and easy individual portions matter more than full-size pantry supply.”
best holiday spreads
What makes a great holiday spread
1
Choose fruit, spice, or cocoa-hazelnut first
The clearest distinction is flavor.
2
Let the package size match your serving habits
For a household that expects to use a spread repeatedly, Bonne Maman’s two 13-ounce jars offer the most listed product by total we
3
Decide whether you need a brunch spread, a baking ingredient, or a gift
For a brunch centerpiece or a small food gift, Stonewall Kitchen has a clear advantage: its holiday fruit blend is distinctive, an
4
Check ingredients and dietary details against your needs
Bonne Maman’s description names pumpkin, sugar, pectin, lemon juice, and spices, and states that it has no high fructose corn syru
How to choose your holiday spread
1
How we picked
I ranked these spreads by how well they suit holiday occasions , not by treating them as interchangeable pantry staples.
2
Choose fruit, spice, or cocoa-hazelnut first
The clearest distinction is flavor.
3
Let the package size match your serving habits
For a household that expects to use a spread repeatedly, Bonne Maman’s two 13-ounce jars offer the most listed product b
4
Decide whether you need a brunch spread, a baking ingredient, or a gift
For a brunch centerpiece or a small food gift, Stonewall Kitchen has a clear advantage: its holiday fruit blend is disti
5
Check ingredients and dietary details against your needs
Bonne Maman’s description names pumpkin, sugar, pectin, lemon juice, and spices, and states that it has no high fructose
Vetted holiday spreads ·
The best holiday spreads, compared
★ Winner Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam
Best Overall — distinctive fruit flavor for holiday brunch
3compared
2flavors

How We Picked

I ranked these spreads by how well they suit holiday occasions, not by treating them as interchangeable pantry staples. I looked at the flavor profile described for each product, how easily it can serve more than one purpose, and whether the package makes sense for a shared table, regular home use, or gifting. Those differences matter: a preserve that works across brunch and baking solves a different need from a set of individual jars intended for sharing.

I also weighed format and practical tradeoffs. Two full-size jars offer more supply for a household than seven mini portions, while a single 12.5-ounce jar can be a more straightforward fit for a host gift or one holiday meal. Flavor was another ranking factor: Stonewall Kitchen’s fruit blend is the most specifically holiday-oriented without relying on a spice profile, Bonne Maman offers familiar pumpkin spices and broad kitchen uses, and Nutella brings a recognizable cocoa-hazelnut option in festive packaging.

The lineup is small and each product has a clearly different role, so I did not rank them as though one flavor should suit every buyer. My top pick is the most distinctive all-around holiday-table option; the next is better for shoppers prioritizing versatility and volume; and the final pick is best when portioning and presentation matter more than having a full-size jar. Product details here reflect the provided descriptions and specifications; I do not imply hands-on testing.

Feature comparison
holiday spreadFlavorPackagingSuggested uses
Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam———
Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice PresPumpkin spiceGlass jarsToast, yogurt, and baking
Nutella Hazelnut Spread with CHazelnut with cocoaFestive ornament packToast, pancakes, waffles, fruit, and baked goods
Everyday → specialist
Everyday & valuePremium & specialist
Which holiday spread fits you?
The everyday user
All-round, reliable
The enthusiast
Premium & high-performance
The gift-giver
Looks & craftsmanship

Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Holiday Spreads

I’d choose among these three by starting with the job the spread needs to do. The flavors are distinct enough that the right pick for brunch may not be the right one for baking or gifting. Match flavor, quantity, and package style to how you plan to serve it, then use the differences below to narrow the choice.

Choose fruit, spice, or cocoa-hazelnut first

The clearest distinction is flavor. Stonewall Kitchen combines pear, cranberry, and raspberry, with a hint of orange liqueur. That gives it the strongest tart-sweet fruit character and makes it the most natural fit for a holiday brunch table where a bright spread can sit alongside richer foods. It is also the only option here with that particular mix of fruit and citrus liqueur.

Bonne Maman goes in a warmer direction: pumpkin paired with cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove. Choose it if you enjoy familiar seasonal spices or want an ingredient to add to breakfast and baking. If pumpkin spice is not a flavor you reach for, its larger format will not make it a better fit. Nutella is different again, with creamy hazelnut and cocoa rather than fruit or pumpkin. Its recognizable, sweeter profile makes it the most distinct alternative for guests who prefer chocolate-like spreads.

Let the package size match your serving habits

For a household that expects to use a spread repeatedly, Bonne Maman’s two 13-ounce jars offer the most listed product by total weight. That format can be divided between ordinary breakfast use and seasonal recipes, or one jar can remain unopened until needed. Stonewall Kitchen supplies one 12.5-ounce jar, a more contained amount for a brunch or gift. The Nutella pack includes seven jars, but each is only 30 grams; it is designed around individual servings rather than a large amount in one container.

Think about how the spread will be opened and served. A full-size jar is more practical when people will help themselves repeatedly or when a recipe calls for a larger quantity. Mini jars make portions easy to hand out, but they can be limiting for toast or baking if you need to open several. Choose volume for regular use and minis for sharing, rather than comparing package count alone.

Decide whether you need a brunch spread, a baking ingredient, or a gift

For a brunch centerpiece or a small food gift, Stonewall Kitchen has a clear advantage: its holiday fruit blend is distinctive, and the product description specifically positions it for brunch and gifting. Nutella’s ornament packaging is the most visibly festive format, with individual jars that can be shared or given as small seasonal portions. Bonne Maman is less focused on presentation, but its two jars and suggested baking uses make it the most practical kitchen pick.

If gifting, consider whether the recipient is likely to use a seasonal flavor. The fruit blend and pumpkin spices both signal a particular time of year; the ornament pack also has holiday-specific packaging. For someone who prefers everyday pantry items, these seasonal cues may be less useful than a more neutral spread. If serving a group with varied tastes, the cocoa-hazelnut minis offer a familiar profile, while the fruit and pumpkin options provide more pronounced seasonal character.

Check ingredients and dietary details against your needs

Bonne Maman’s description names pumpkin, sugar, pectin, lemon juice, and spices, and states that it has no high fructose corn syrup or artificial flavors. It also lists Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, and kosher certifications. Those details distinguish it from the shorter specifications provided for the other products, but they do not replace checking the current package if an ingredient or dietary restriction matters to you.

Stonewall Kitchen lists its fruit ingredients and a hint of orange liqueur; Nutella is described as a hazelnut spread with cocoa. The supplied details do not provide full ingredient statements or allergen information for those products. I would check their labels directly before serving them to anyone with allergies or specific dietary requirements. Do not infer suitability from flavor descriptions alone, especially when a spread will be shared at a group gathering.

Treat seasonality as part of the tradeoff

Each product has a holiday or seasonal angle, but that shows up differently. Stonewall Kitchen’s fruit blend is explicitly holiday-themed, Bonne Maman’s pumpkin spice leans into a seasonal flavor, and Nutella’s ornament pack uses seasonal packaging around a familiar spread. If you want a product that feels tied to the occasion, those cues help. If you want one jar to stay in regular rotation, the same cues may narrow when you feel like using it.

For the most flexible use across occasions, I’d compare the actual flavor you enjoy rather than assuming a larger pack is automatically better. Bonne Maman has the broadest stated use range across toast, yogurt, and baking, but its spice profile remains specific. Stonewall Kitchen can work at brunch and as a gift, while Nutella has several suggested foods but comes in small portions. The best holiday spread is the one whose seasonal flavor you will finish, not simply the one with the most festive label.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which of these holiday spreads is best for brunch?

Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam is my first choice for a fruit-forward brunch because its pears, cranberries, raspberries, and hint of orange liqueur create a clear tart-sweet contrast. Bonne Maman is a better match for guests who want pumpkin spice, while Nutella suits those who prefer cocoa and hazelnut in individual portions. Choose based on the flavors you want to serve, rather than expecting one jar to suit every palate.

Which spread is best for baking?

Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves is the most direct pick for seasonal baking: the product description specifically suggests baking, and the two-jar pack gives you more supply than Nutella’s mini jars. Stonewall Kitchen may appeal if you want a fruit-led flavor, but the listed uses emphasize brunch and gifting. Nutella can also be used with baked goods, though the small jars may be inconvenient for recipes that call for more than a little spread.

Which option is best for gifting?

For a single seasonal jar, Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam is described as suitable for host or holiday gifting and has a distinctive fruit blend. For a more overtly festive presentation with individual portions, choose Nutella’s ornament pack. Bonne Maman offers two glass jars and useful kitchen versatility, but its strongest case is quantity and cooking use rather than individual gift presentation. The recipient’s flavor preferences should guide the final choice.

Which product gives me the most spread?

Bonne Maman has the largest listed total amount: two 13-ounce jars, or 26 ounces altogether. Stonewall Kitchen has one 12.5-ounce jar, while the Nutella pack totals 7 ounces across seven mini jars. Package size is only useful if you like the flavor, though; the pumpkin-spice profile may be less appealing to someone who would rather finish a fruit jam or cocoa-hazelnut spread.

Are these spreads suitable for dietary restrictions?

The provided details list Bonne Maman as gluten-free and kosher and identify it as Non-GMO Project Verified; they also state that it contains sugar. Full ingredient and allergen details are not supplied for all three products, and Stonewall Kitchen’s description mentions orange liqueur. I recommend reading the current package labels and checking with the manufacturer when an allergy, dietary restriction, or ingredient limit affects your purchase.

Conclusion

For most holiday brunch tables, I’d choose Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam: its fruit blend is the most distinctive, and the single jar suits serving or seasonal gifting without committing to a large quantity. If you want a spread for repeated breakfasts and seasonal recipes, Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves is the better match thanks to its two full-size jars and stated uses in toast, yogurt, and baking. For hosts or gift-givers who value individual portions and festive packaging, Nutella’s ornament pack is the clear specialist pick.

My ranking comes down to how broadly each product can serve a holiday occasion: Stonewall Kitchen leads on distinctive brunch flavor, Bonne Maman on supply and kitchen use, and Nutella on sharing. Choose the profile you and your guests will actually enjoy, and check package labels for ingredient or dietary needs before serving.

You May Also Like

15 Best Halloween Advent Calendars for Spooky Seasonal Fun in 2027

Compare 15 Halloween advent calendars, from plush and candy to crafts and collectibles, and choose the right countdown for your household.

10 Best Espresso Machines for Every Budget: Quality Brews Without Breaking the Bank

Discover the best espresso machines for your budget in 2026. Find top picks like the Breville BES870XL and budget-friendly options for every level.

15 Best Easy-to-Use Robotic Pool Cleaners That Make Maintenance a Breeze

Discover the best easy to use robotic pool cleaners in 2026. Find top picks including the best overall, value, and beginner-friendly options in this detailed guide.

14 Best Suction Pool Cleaners for Sand and Dirt That Keep Your Pool Spotless

Compare 14 pool cleaners for sand and dirt, from suction-side models to cordless vacuums, and choose by debris, pool type, and maintenance needs.